Most competitive decks I’ve seen focus on other vendors: their strengths and weaknesses, and how the company compares.
But when a deal slips, the prospect may not have chosen another vendor. It may have kept the spreadsheet, stayed with its existing supplier, brought the work in-house, or decided to wait.
None of those alternatives will show up on a conventional battlecard.
What the buyer is really comparing
I find it more useful to start with a different question: What would this buyer do if our offer were unavailable?
April Dunford makes competitive alternatives the starting point for positioning. That changes what you compare yourself against. The relevant alternative could be another vendor, a manual workflow, a hire, an existing platform used for a different job, or continuing as before. They give you a starting point for explaining what a buyer would gain by choosing your offer.
While researching how food processors buy plant-floor software, I came across a software vendor’s 2019 case study. The processor used accounting software, a separate finished-goods system and spreadsheets in each department. The numbers didn’t match, and Finance couldn’t follow the cost of ingredients through to the finished product.
That’s where I’d start the competitive analysis. The case study describes what the processor eventually bought, but it doesn’t explain what other options it considered. Looking at that setup, I can see several possibilities: keep reconciling by hand, add a tool that works with the accounting system, or replace more of the setup. Each option comes with a different amount of work for the plant and for Finance. Before you show them a feature comparison, show what they’d keep, what they’d have to change, and which manual steps would go away.
Why the existing approach often survives
For a processor in that position, keeping the existing systems and reconciling the numbers by hand could be a sensible choice. The manual work takes time, but switching systems may disrupt a plant that needs to keep production running. A buyer needs to weigh the cost of the current process against the work and risk of changing it. Waiting can be a rational decision.
A pitch that only explains superiority over Vendor A may leave the internal champion unable to answer a more basic objection: Why change now, and what happens if we don't?
Rebuild the comparison around the buyer's choices
I would do a short alternatives review before revising the competitive deck. Pick five recent opportunities, including a win, a named-competitor loss, a delayed or no-decision deal, and an active evaluation. Look at call notes, win/loss conversations and what the buyer actually said. Avoid guessing from the CRM's competitor field.
For each opportunity, record five things:
What job was the buyer trying to get done, and what event made it worth discussing?
What would they keep using or do instead if they didn't buy from us?
Which people or teams would have to change their work?
What made the alternative attractive and what specific cost, delay or risk would justify switching?
What evidence would the buying group need to decide that the new approach is worth it?
Cluster the answers into a small number of alternatives: named providers, incumbent tool or provider, manual/internal process, build or hire, and defer. Include only the clusters supported by actual buyer evidence. Focus on the options buyers actually considered.
Then change the messaging
If prospects are comparing your platform with a manual workflow, explain the operating problem and the effort to change it. If they are deciding whether to build internally, show where your expertise, capacity or how quickly they could see a return makes a difference. If the decision is being deferred, give the champion a credible case for acting, including the conditions under which waiting would be reasonable.
Take the processor again. If the alternative is another year of reconciling by hand, Finance needs to see how ingredient costs would carry through to the finished product. The plant manager needs to know what would change on the floor and how the switch would be managed while production continues. A customer story that explains how a similar plant made the change could help both assess the risk.
Named rivals still matter. Product, sales and marketing teams need to understand their offers and their claims. They also need a view of the paths a real buyer could take without choosing any of them.
Before the next battlecard update, pull up your last five decisions and ask what each buyer actually compared. Then check whether your homepage and sales deck give buyers evidence against those options, including the option of changing nothing.
If you’d like help reviewing the alternatives your buyers consider, take a look at my Market and Category Strategy work.

